This is my personal view and comments on the issues and events that I feel a need to talk about or express my view. You don't have to agree, but lets carry on a adult, discussion and maybe you will see it the right way, mine. ;)
Iraqs turning in the bad guys, guess they like us a little..
Published on April 20, 2005 By ShadowWar In Current Events
CAMP LIBERTY, Iraq — U.S. and Iraqi security forces say they are gaining ground on insurgents and criminals because more Iraqis are phoning tips to a hotline set up in October.

The hotline, known as the Joint Operating Center, has fielded about 1,100 calls in six months, dramatically improving street-level intelligence, says Army Sgt. Major Jerry Craig, a military policeman who oversees the call center. Most of the tips have come from anonymous tipsters. “Not only have the calls increased, the calls that give us actionable intelligence have increased, and our success rate has improved,” Craig says. The center, which is inside the Army’s heavily guarded Camp Liberty near the Baghdad International Airport, forwards callers’ tips to U.S. and Iraqi security forces for investigation. Since October, 82 percent of callers have offered information on insurgent actions directed against Iraqi security forces, Craig says. Seven percent have reported crimes. Eleven percent haven’t been useful. The hotline phone number is plastered on Baghdad billboards and printed on thousands of key chains and business cards handed out by security forces in the capital. One week earlier this month, the call center fielded 53 tips. Thirty-one callers gave information about attacks — or planned assaults — on security forces. Four tips dealt with murders, three with carjackings, two with bombs. The center provided computer printouts of several recent tips to the hotline — with some details blacked out for security reasons.

The information included:

• The location of 32 bodies, phoned in by a woman who identified herself as the mother of a man murdered by insurgents.

• The identity of a Baghdad coffee shop owner who was brokering ransom demands for insurgent kidnappers. The caller said the kidnappers had snatched 15 victims and murdered seven.

• The address of an insurgent who was staying in a house fortified by rocket launchers.

• Details on a reputed terrorist cell linked to the murders of Iraqi police and national guardsmen.

Despite improved intelligence, most Baghdad police continue to work at offices throughout the city without basic tools such as cell phones, computers and training. Still, Gen. Hussein Kamal, the intelligence chief at the Interior Ministry, is upbeat. Iraqi residents “are starting to realize the weakness and falsehood of the insurgency when they see a lot of the insurgents falling to our hands,” he says. Kamal says tips from residents led to large-scale raids on insurgent camps at Salah al-Din province, west of Baghdad, on March 22, and at Salman Pak, south of Baghdad, the next day. He calls the raids potential turning points in the drive against insurgents. “Time is in our favor,” he says. “We are improving our security, police and military. I assure you, the conflict will end in our favor.”

Comments
on Apr 20, 2005
Anonymous tipsters will never provide accurate intelligence consistently. For one thing, every community in North America has anonymous tip lines for cash rewards. It does nothing to deter crime or to prevent crimes from occuring. Just as you cannot win a war with only air power, likewise you cannot win a war through anonymous tipsters. And this is why: the benefits, most likely a cash reward, will make it too simple for people to say whatever in order to get some cash reward. There's something totally wrong about this. Think about it people. Think hard. The only thing the nationalist Iraqis a.k.a. mislabelled insurgent, needs to do to counter this threat is picking up a phone, and make up lies to tie up American's manpower. You want to kill a few Americans? Phone in a bogus tip about some scary terrorists hiding somewhere, then blow the investigating American's bodies to pieces while hiding with a remote detonator. People should realize this tactic will not work any better than it does here. The one problem is the poverty in Iraq. Add that to cash rewards for tips, and you have tons of Iraqis who want free money proving they say what the Americans want to hear. Don't be fooled into thinking the monies are only dispursed once the facts prove true or not. That is not the case since it's an impossible situation. If that were the case, all a freedom-loving Iraqi nationalist has to do is get a job working for the US (risking his life unless local nationalists know he's working against the occupation) and get details as to the informers' identities. Or simply sit ten blocks away with even low-quality battleship binoculars and identify the spies who give information, bogus or not, to the Americans. It's really a no-win situation. The supposed informers can lie, which in turn ties up valuable resources. They can sit and watch which Iraqis come and go from the US installation. They can create false details which again will tie up the US investigators. If the nationalists want to strike a target in south Baghdad, they need only to send in false tips regarding some terrorist safe-houses in North Baghdad, which will take up valuable resources. Keep in mind people that this isn't like home, where the tip line gets a tip, and the dispatcher sends the authorities to the location provided from the tipster. This is Iraq, where all Iraqis are suspect, which explains their being continually slaughtered by trigger happy and terrified American adolescents. The logistics involved consumes too much time to be effective. Manpower, armored escort, making sure they have enough firepower to face whoever is the targets of the tips, making sure they have backup in the form of a fast-strike military unit who are prepared to face whatever threat there may be, making sure they have adequate air support should the need arise....then there's the human element, where innocent people must be separated from the Iraqi nationalist fighters in order to keep innocent death figures down. And that's where the US will continually fail in Iraq. They have to shoot and ask questions later which guarantees more faithful Iraqi converts who wish to avenge their loved ones' deaths. Unlike most of America, I know and understand that with each innocent Iraqi death, there are at least 2 Iraqi's willing to avenge their deaths. Think again people! Is there anything more honorable than killing a foreign invader who occupies your land and who rapes your women? Of course not. Incidents like that are in fact the main reason for legal warfare. Historically, the Iraqis with their situation have the upper hand and armed force will never be able to stop the bleeding. Only peaceful intentions can do that, and we all know the Americans have no peaceful intentions for Iraq. It's a colossal theft of resources and we all should understand that theft always includes some form of defensive measure i.e. killing whatever is trying to stop you from stealing. No nation can bring weapons to a foreign land if they wish to have some measure of peace. And we know that.
on Apr 20, 2005
Reiki-house,

You evidently have no clue how these things work. Its not like they get a call and go running to check it out. Think about it man. Your rant leaves out one very important thing, the tip line IS WORKING, as cited by the calls that actually led to something. Your forgetting the fact the VAST majority of Iraqis are helping, working, or at least not interfering with the Military forces there. You rant as if the war is not being won. It is not only being won, but is actually getting better and the Iraqis are doing more and more of the work. Take a breath and look at reality. The Iraq situation is getting more and more in the direction of the Iraqi self governing and taking care of their own national security. Peace brother... breath deep and be glad are armed forces are as good as they are, it could have been far worse.
on Apr 20, 2005
You see they are filtering out the calls that lead to nothing: Since October, 82 percent of callers have offered information on insurgent actions directed against Iraqi security forces, Craig says. Seven percent have reported crimes. Eleven percent haven’t been useful.